Should You Have a Co-Host for Your Podcast? Let’s Find Out!

Hey there, fellow podcasters! Today, I’m venturing a bit out of my comfort zone. As someone who usually talks about things I know well, this episode is a bit different. We’re diving into a topic I’m not an expert on, but I know it’s on your mind: having a co-host for your podcast. This is about practicing what I preach—getting out of my comfort zone to help you do the same. Let’s see if having a co-host is the right move for your podcast!

No Personal Co-Host Experience

First things first, I don’t have personal experience with co-hosting a podcast. I’ve never had a permanent co-host, but I know it’s a popular topic among podcasters. Many people in our Proffitt Podcast community and other podcasting groups often ask, “Should I have a co-host?” It’s a question worth exploring. Even if you’re currently flying solo, a friend might approach you one day to start a podcast together.

So today, I want to share five things to consider when thinking about a co-host, plus some pros and cons of having one. And, of course, I’ll share some great co-hosted podcasts that I love.

Things to Consider

1. Scheduling

Let’s start with the basics: scheduling. It’s a big deal. I’ve heard stories where one co-host is super into it, while the other is less committed. You need to find a co-host whose schedule aligns with yours.

I’m a planner; I plan my week every Sunday, so teaming up with someone who’s not organized wouldn’t work for me. For example, someone who wants to record at 10 PM wouldn’t be a good fit since I’m usually asleep by then. Having a schedule you both agree on is essential, whether it’s recording once a month or weekly.

2. Motivation Levels

Motivation levels are crucial. You don’t want to partner with someone who isn’t as passionate as you are. Imagine being excited about podcasting while your co-host is lukewarm about the idea. It wouldn’t work!

Make sure your co-host shares your enthusiasm for the topic. You both need to bring energy to the table. Otherwise, it’s like dragging a weight behind you—your co-host should lift you, not hold you back.

3. Goals

Your goals should align. Are you podcasting for fun, or is it a stepping stone to something bigger? Make sure you’re on the same page. If one person wants to monetize the podcast while the other just wants to chat, it’ll lead to tension. Discuss your goals upfront to avoid misunderstandings.

4. Consistency

Consistency ties back to scheduling. Are you committed to releasing episodes regularly? Consistency is key to building a loyal audience. Your listeners need to know when to expect new episodes. Whether you’re publishing weekly or monthly, be consistent to become part of your audience’s routine.

5. Messaging

Finally, your messaging should be cohesive. Even if you have different opinions, your overall message should align. A podcast where co-hosts constantly contradict each other can confuse and alienate listeners. Ensure your messaging is clear and unified, even if you have differing views.

Co-Host Pros and Cons

Now that we’ve covered what to consider, let’s talk about some pros and cons of having a co-host.

Pros:

1. You’re Not Alone: You have someone to chat with, making the podcast more dynamic. It’s less awkward than talking to yourself, and you can bounce ideas off each other.
2. Shared Expertise: You can rely on your co-host’s knowledge. It’s like having a brainstorming partner who brings fresh perspectives to the table.
3. Social Aspect: It’s fun to connect with someone regularly. It can be a great way to maintain social interactions, especially if you’re working from home.

Cons:

1. Outgrowing Each Other: You might start at the same level, but what happens if one of you grows faster? It can create tension if you’re not prepared.
2. Disagreements: If one person wants out, how do you handle it? It’s important to have a plan for splitting assets and revenue if things don’t work out.
3. Financial Considerations: If your podcast becomes profitable, how do you divide the income? Discuss these details early to avoid complications down the line.

Examples of Co-Hosted Podcasts

If you’re considering having a co-host, check out these fantastic podcasts for inspiration. These hosts have nailed the dynamic duo (or trio) approach.

1. Office Ladies

Hosted by Jenna Fischer and Angela Kinsey (Pam and Angela from The Office), this podcast is a must-listen. Their real-life friendship and behind-the-scenes stories from The Office make for a fantastic show. They’re a great example of co-hosts with an established relationship.

2. Smartless

Hosted by Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, and Will Arnett, Smartless is a comedic podcast where the hosts interview interesting guests. Their long-standing friendship makes for a fun and engaging show. Their dynamic is proof that a trio can work if the chemistry is right.

3. Sibling Revelry

Hosted by Kate Hudson and Oliver Hudson, this podcast explores sibling relationships and features guests like Gary Chapman (of The Five Love Languages fame). Their sibling banter and unique perspective make for a lively podcast.

4. Armchair Expert

Dax Shepard and Monica Padman host this show, offering deep conversations with fascinating guests. Their connection is genuine, and their differing perspectives create engaging discussions. Their friendship adds authenticity to the podcast.

Final Thoughts

Considering a co-host for your podcast? Take your time to evaluate the pros and cons, align your goals, and ensure your schedules and messaging match up. Listen to these co-hosted podcasts for inspiration and see what works well. Remember, a successful podcast partnership requires communication and collaboration.

If you’re ready to take the plunge, go for it! You might find that having a co-host is the perfect way to elevate your podcast and reach new heights.

That’s all for today. For more insights, check out the show notes at KrystalProffitt.com/Episode235. Don’t forget to subscribe and share your thoughts on social media. And as always, keep it up. We all have to start somewhere.